Caterers
2nd Ave Deli
Meat
Phone: 212-689-9000
Contact: Steve Cohen
https://2ndavedeli.com
Bagel Boss
Dairy
Phone: (212) 388-9292
Contact: Michael
Note: they have now added a non-kosher location in Manhattan in addition to their two longstanding kosher locations, so please make sure you’re ordering from the location on 1st & 15th or the location on 3rd and 36th only. The 1st Ave location is who we typically work with and therefore knows us better.
Colbeh
Meat
Phone: (516) 801-0800
Contact: pejman@colbeh.com
https://www.colbeh.com/catering/
Hummus Kitchen
Meat (many fish/pareve options)
Phone: (212) 988-0090 (UES), (212) 333-3009 (Hell’s Kitchen)
https://hummuskitchen.com/
Note: the Chelsea location is not kosher and the Murray Hill location is not certified
Majestic Kosher Catering
Dairy
Phone: 516-205-2737 (am), 516-791-3848 (pm)
Contact: Bobby Leshansky
Park East Kosher
Meat, limited cold dairy options
Phone: 212-737-9800
https://www.parkeastkosher.com/
Pride
Meat, Dairy
Phone: 201-410-3278
Contact: Marty Grossel
https://pridecaterers.net
Village Crown
Meat, Dairy
Phone: 212-207-3888
Contact: Moriah
https://www.villagecrown.com
Gila's Nosh - Mediterranean Kitchen
Meat, Dairy
Phone: 212-213-3334
gilasnosh@gmail.com
Bakeries
Buttercup Bakeshop*
Dairy
Phone: (212) 350-4144
https://www.buttercupbakeshop.com/
Green’s
Pareve
https://www.greensbabka.com/
*make high-quality kosher wedding/event cakes
Michaeli
Dairy
Phone: (646) 360-2284
https://www.michaelibakery.com/
World of Chantilly*
Dairy, Pareve
Phone: (718) 859-1110
https://chantilly.com/
Flowers
Gramercy Florist
Phone: 212-475-4989
Contact: Tom or Lynie
https://www.gramercyflowers.com
Wine and Liquor
Wine:
Kosherwine.com
https://www.kosherwine.com/
Astor Wine and Spirits
https://www.astorwines.com/
The Morton Williams Wine Store on Park, Astor Wines & Spirits, and Union Square Wines & Spirits all have substantial kosher selections if you prefer to browse in person/buy a few bottles to try before placing a bulk order.
Liquor:
Warehouse Wine & Spirits
https://warehousewinesandspirits.com/
Search “kosher” on the Warehouse to find a wide selection of certified kosher liquor. Generally, unflavored grain spirits are fine without certification. It’s the synagogue’s policy to permit liquors aged in sherry casks. Grape spirits always need supervision. Other flavored spirits vary and there are many resources online, such as the CRC and Star-K lists. Feel free to call the office with questions, they will be redirected to the rabbi as needed.
Party goods (tablecloths, plates, balloons, etc.)
Alan Party Rental
Phone: 201-288-3700
http://www.alanpartyrentals.com
Party City
38 West 14 Street
Phone: 929-523-2739
https://stores.partycity.com/us/ny/newyork/party-store-pc681.html